Bank On This! (How to Stop Fighting About Money)

How to Stop Fighting About Money

Photo © Depositphotos.com/Goodluz

Today, Joanne Miller joins us again to share how she and Dan have gone years without a money fight. What a perfect follow-up to Derek's post from Monday!  Be sure to share your money and marriage stories in the comments!

Let’s face it. The number one argument on the frequency scale that most couples have is about money.

I can hear your head nodding as you are reading. I certainly know it was often a bone of contention for us. I lost count of how many Christmas holidays rolled around when Dan and I would have our annual battle over how many gifts I wanted to buy for family members….and friends…..not to mention all the gifts I wanted to pile under our tree from Santa and from us.

Oh yes, money was an issue for us. For many years, in fact.

Until we came up with THE PLAN.

Best thing we ever did for our marriage and if you are a husband reading this, listen up!

Writing from the woman’s point of view, and from a Christian perspective, I think a married woman who doesn’t have her own checking account is a recipe for marital disharmony.

Now I know all the scripture about becoming one flesh and so on. But I don’t really think there is a passage in the Good Book that addresses separate versus joint bank accounts. And for many years I never considered having my own account. After all, I didn’t have a job outside the home so I didn’t have income. So why would I have a checking account?

We always had a joint account but that meant everything I spent I was accountable for. And vice versa. Everything had to be justified and talked about and sometimes argued about. But once Dan and I figured out THE PLAN, we haven’t had a money argument in years.

Not a one. THE PLAN really works!

THE PLAN

First we looked at an average of our monthly output on groceries including toiletries, cleaning and laundry products which were sometimes bought at separate stores.

We itemized what I spent on getting my hair done, manicures, pedicures (these were AFTER the kids were out of the house. Before that I did my own), and we estimated what I needed for gifts for birthdays, anniversaries, Christmas, etc.

We looked at what we spent on clothes and shoes and estimated that for a year and after totaling up all those expenses, we came up with a yearly total, divided that by twelve months and padded it a little for unexpected needs and came up with a monthly figure we could both agree on.

We decided I would “get paid” twice a month, the first and the fifteenth. I didn’t have to ask for it, it was just given to me in a check or transferred into my account. As the years have passed, I have occasionally asked for a pay increase and sometimes even had to have an advance. But this system was so freeing for both of us that I don’t think we ever made a more important change in our habits that has so greatly relieved stress and frustration.

Here’s why THE PLAN was important in our marriage.

Every time I needed money, whether it was for some extra groceries, school supplies for the kids, a gift for a baby shower, I felt like a little child going to my Daddy asking if he could please give me the money.

It felt demeaning to me. Sometimes I would feel on the defensive and like I had to justify why I needed this money and hope he approved. Our discussions about money were always frustrating to both of us.

When we decided to have me open my own account I felt like a weight had been lifted from my shoulders. I no longer have to ask for money.

I keep my checkbook balanced to the penny and I know how to stretch a dollar that makes my husband proud. If I want to buy a gift for a friend or take a grandchild to the movie I don’t have to wonder where the money will come from.

I manage my own finances and it is a great feeling. I don’t handle the mortgage, gas in my car (he knows I hate to fill up), insurance, and major purchases for the house or a car. Dan handles that.

Now at Christmas I have money to spend however I want because I even have my own savings account. We still have a joint account and Dan has his various business accounts.

I happily “get paid” twice monthly and account only to myself for how that is spent. Yep! Best thing we ever did for our marriage. It’ll make you feel like a real grown up.

I highly recommend it.

Joanne Miller has been happily married for over four decades to career coach and author Dan Miller (48 Days To the Work You Love).  She has authored four children’s books and has a new book for grown ups co-authored with artist Dorsey McHugh called Be Your Finest ArtShe and Dan have three grown children and twelve grandchildren and lots of years living the entrepreneurial roller-coaster life of adventure!

Mailbag and Confessions Around the Web

What I Wore / Foter / CC BY

What an amazing week!   I spent a few days down in Atlanta working on the book.  It was awesome.  I'll have a HUGE announcement about it next week.  A huge, scary announcement.  That's it on the book for now.  But the draft is coming along.

The blog will also be refreshed.  I'm definitely going to keep it simple.  But I'll be using a new theme that will allow me to interact with you much better than I can now.  It will also be slightly prettier, which is obviously not very difficult to accomplish….

Before I get into the mailbag I want to quickly honor and thank the sites around the web that have sent readers over here.

Some of these were direct posts referring to this site and others were through their brilliant and attractive readers who interacted with me through comments!

Here they are.  Confessions Around the Web:

Funny About Money

Budgeting in the Fun Stuff

Jennifer Kaufman (also tweeted – thanks!)

Wealth Lion

Budgets Are Sexy (also spread the good word through twitter)

Simple Mom

Another special thanks to those who tweeted about the site:  

Daniel Jones

Mike Loomis

Your Daily Finance

Tyrone Ioane

David Kozlowski

Stephen WG

Holly Douglas

You all rock!    Thank you.

The best compliment really is a referral.  So let me know if you find (or refer to) this site around the web, so I can properly thank you!

OK.  Here are the three most frequently asked questions from the past week.  Be sure to reach out through the feedback form if you have a question.  I respond to them all and will put the most frequently asked ones up in the next mailbag, too.  Here's the last mailbag, in case you missed it.

How is becoming a better husband going?

It's going well.  But it's tough.  I am getting great tips, tricks and encouragement from all over the place, which is helping a lot.  Just check out the comments on my posts!  The people who come here are really awesome and genuinely want to help.  Whether it's through sharing what worked for them in similar situations or just a quick “we got your back,” it's really awesome and helps a ton.  That makes it a lot easier!

What's been the toughest part?

Fighting my mind.  I've spent years trying to be fair or avoiding commitment.  That's hard to change overnight.  Getting up is simple.  Still tough to do, but a simple concept.  The mental part of it is a grind.

Do you ever want to give up?

Nah.  What's the alternative?  I've had moments where I've wanted to take a nap or go for a walk.  I've had moments where I think or say something stupid.  I've been tired.  And I've been lazy at times.  But there are fewer and fewer of those moments, which is awesome. Giving up is not an option.  The alternative is way worse than the hard work.  In other words, it's way more “worth it” than it is “hard.”

Awesome!  There you have it.  Be sure to stop by and say hello!  Leave a comment.  Use the feedback form.  Or shoot me an e-mail at nick (at) aterriblehusband (dot) com.  I read and reply to them all.  You can also find me on twitter at a bad husband.  That's probably the easiest way to interact on a “real time” basis.  But I also reply to all comments here, too.  And bloggers love comments almost as much as they love twitter followers…. maybe more.  So don't be shy!